I was nearly done with a revision of my debut middle grade novel when a pitch contest popped up on Twitter. One of my writing friends egged me on to throw a pitch out there, and I figured it couldn’t hurt! Shockingly, I received a request from an agent and had to spend the weekend frantically revising the book and researching agents to cold query. I was fortunate to receive several offers of representation, one of which was from a newer agent from a prestigious firm. As is typical, he offered to have me speak with an author he’d worked with at the firm. That author was Nicholas Sparks.
This installment of Mel’s Notebook is emailed to paid subscribers every Thursday at 9AM EST. If you would also like to receive it by email, become a paid subscriber and and get a peek behind the scenes of my creative life!
Now it’s really important to set the stage here: I did not have any preexisting connections in the literary world when this happened. I am not the relative of anyone famous, nor did I have a big social media platform. I had no credentials other than the manuscript I cold queried my agent with, and yet, I ended up picking up a call early one morning and hearing the words, “Hello, this is Nicholas Sparks. Isn’t that wild?”
Now, nothing prepares a newbie writer to speak with someone who has this much experience in the industry. I was awed by his casual demeanor and the ease with which he dispensed invaluable insights about publishing and how I should make my decision about which agent to work with. One of the agents was a pretty big name. They had a long roster of established authors and lots of sales. The other agent was younger and I would be their first signed client, but at a firm with a long track record of success. The advice Nicholas Sparks gave me that morning made it clear which agent would benefit me most at that point in my career. He said:




