When I decided to write a #metoo story set in middle school, I knew I would face some opposition from adult readers. Adults don’t like to talk about uncomfortable subjects. They don’t WANT their children dealing with misogyny or sexual harassment, so they avoid any mention of these topics, especially books that talk about them. They think they can keep their children safe by avoiding anything heavy or uncomfortable, so they don’t appreciate it that I talk about these things in my books. But I’m not writing for the adults. My books are for the kids.
This installment of Mel’s Notebook is emailed to paid subscribers every Thursday at 9AM EST. If you would also like to receive it by email, become a paid subscriber and earn access to my full archives along with my undying gratitude!
Last fall, when I attended the Princeton Children’s Book Festival, I had a very eager young reader approach my table early in the day. She said she was in middle school and she was excited to find new books because she was a big reader. Her father smiled nervously as I told her about my books. Her face lit up when I pitched Crushed, my #metoo story set in middle school. She grabbed the book and hugged it against her chest. “I want this one,” she told her dad.
“Maybe we should look around and see what else there is,” he said.
“I want this one,” she repeated.
The father looked at me and said, “I don’t think I want you reading about all that social media stuff. Then you’ll want me to get you a phone.”
“No I won’t,” she said, her eyes narrowing.
“Maybe you should take a look around,” I said. “You can always come back later.”
She looked at me with steely resolve in her eyes. “Okay.”
The father mouthed the words thank you at me as they departed my table. Other readers soon took my attention. I signed for hours. My book stacks shrunk. I was nearly sold out of Crushed when the girl from earlier reappeared. “This one,” she said as she grabbed one of the last copies. “I looked at all the other books,” she told me with a smirk. The father shrugged, helpless.
I couldn’t help laughing. When readers know what they want, they know. Adults who try to intervene are merely obstacles to circumvent. And hey, I get it. The father was genuinely concerned about opening this can of worms, but what he failed to realize is that the can was already open. The young people of today are living very different childhoods than we did. They need more resources, and they need them earlier.
This week, I met with young readers across the country for World Read Aloud Day, a global celebration of reading and literacy. On this day, authors connect with readers virtually to read together. I usually read a brief excerpt from one of my books. This year, with everything happening in the news and in the United States, I knew exactly which selections I wanted to read. Here are those pages from Crushed:
Yep, my middle grade fiction talks about democracy and autocracy because IT HAS TO. This is the world these children are living in. To paint it any other way would be to deny their reality. I am not about to do that. I don’t care how many adults get upset with me. I’m going to share knowledge and explore provocative situations that encourage young people to use their critical thinking skills and figure out what they think for themselves.
That doesn’t mean it’s not scary to speak out. It is scary. But it also my moral duty as a creator to create with integrity. It is our role as artists to provoke. We are keen observers. We see connections that others do not. It is our obligation to point to them, to question them, to ask WHY THIS???
If you are fearful of speaking your mind, let me reassure you: your universal values will show in your work whether you directly engage with them or not. If you have contempt for a certain kind of person, situation, or action, your art will reflect those deep seated feelings. Remember, your subconscious is driving. It knows how you feel. It will come across in your tone, in your word choice, and your plot twists. You cannot escape your own values, so you might as well embrace them.
In my next novel, I’m taking on puberty, body image, and self hate. Here’s a preview from my notebook for this project:







